Monday, November 16, 2026

Synagogue protester calls new Ann Arbor law an attack on free speech, others applaud it

 

Synagogue protester calls new Ann Arbor law an attack on free speech, others applaud it

Ann Arbor City Council
Henry Herskovitz, wearing a "Save America, End Israel" shirt, attends the Ann Arbor City Council meeting Nov. 5, 2026, with a sign reading "Jewish Power vs. 1st Amendment. Who will win?" He has led weekly Saturday protests outside the Beth Israel synagogue on Washtenaw Avenue for 23 years. (Ryan Stanton | MLive.com)Ryan Stanton | The Ann Arbor News

ANN ARBOR, MI — A new law in Ann Arbor explicitly prohibits disturbing the peace at places of worship or criminally interfering with access to them.

City Council voted 9-0 Thursday, Nov. 5, to give final approval to the ordinance after 23 years of weekly Saturday protests outside the Beth Israel synagogue on Washtenaw Avenue.

It’s intended to replicate a New York law that prohibits engaging in conduct within 50 feet of a place of worship that causes anyone seeking to enter or exit to reasonably fear for their safety. That includes threatening, harassing or intimidating behavior.

It also states it’s illegal to obstruct or otherwise interfere with an entry or exit to render passage unreasonably difficult or hazardous.

A violation is a misdemeanor crime punishable by up to 90 days in jail and/or a fine up to $500.

Police may establish security perimeters for safety extending beyond 50 feet, the ordinance indicates.

Jewish community members and congregants applauded council’s move. They have described the protests outside Beth Israel as hateful and antisemitic, saying they cause fear of violence.

Protesters have carried signs with anti-Jewish and anti-Israel messages like “Jewish Power Corrupts,” “Jews Out of Palestine,” “End Israel” and “Israel: No Right To Exist,” while calling to stop U.S. military aid to Israel and end violence against Palestinians.

Beth Israel protest
Henry Herskovitz leads a protest with anti-Israel and anti-Jewish messages during Hanukkah outside the Beth Israel Congregation in Ann Arbor on Dec. 28, 2019.Ryan Stanton | The Ann Arbor News

Local resident Henry Herskovitz, a self-described former Jew, has led the small gatherings. He says he’s exposing “Jewish supremacism,” calling Israel’s attacks against Palestinians in Gaza a genocide.

Herskovitz appeared in the council chambers Thursday with a sign reading “Jewish Power vs. 1st Amendment. Who will win?” The ordinance is an assault on free speech rights, he said, arguing the protests are peaceful.

“We have never sought to physically dissuade congregants from entering the building. If Beth Israel Jews want to pray for the IDF soldiers committing a genocide on our watch, we say let them,” he said, referring to the Israel Defense Forces.

Herskovitz took issue with establishing an area around the synagogue “where free speech will be suspended.”

“Why not just toss the whole First Amendment into the memory hole and be done with it?” he said.

It’s clear it’s not his group’s presence, but its message, that upsets Beth Israel congregants, as counterprotesters with pro-Israel messages are welcomed, Herskovitz said.

“The First Amendment is content neutral — your job is to protect it, not to destroy it,” he told council.

Ann Arbor City Council
Mayor Christopher Taylor leads his last Ann Arbor City Council meeting Nov. 5, 2026. (Ryan Stanton | MLive.com)Ryan Stanton | The Ann Arbor News

Mayor Christopher Taylor said the protests are abhorrent and make worship challenging. Protesters still have the right to occupy the sidewalk and express themselves and the law does not interfere with that, he said.

What it does is articulate a standard of disorderly conduct that is prohibited and provides some protection to people who are just trying to get to synagogue, he said.

Beth Israel Executive Director Gerald Sorokin said nobody at his synagogue is questioning the right of protesters to express their views and they’re welcome to be offensive.

“What we want made clear is that our community, our members, our guests, do not feel comfortable entering the synagogue,” he said.

“We think that giving our members and our community the opportunity to enter the synagogue without fear of harassment is the most important thing.”

Ann Arbor residents Alan Haber and Odile Hugonot Haber joined Herskovitz in questioning the ordinance.

“The state has no business getting involved in the questions of the church, and this church is supporting a regime with its flag,” Alan Haber said, arguing protesting seems appropriate.

“Why would you want to interfere at all?” he asked.

Beth Israel Congregation protest
Henry Herskovitz, founder of an anti-Israel protest group in Ann Arbor, and Donald Abdul Roberts, holding an anti-Israel flag, kick off another day of protesting outside the Beth Israel Congregation on Washtenaw Avenue on a Saturday morning in August 2013.Ryan Stanton | The Ann Arbor News

The protests have not been without incident. Herskovitz has as YouTube channel documenting encounters with critics, including a July 4 incident in which counterprotester Patrick Convery said he was shoved and strangled when he tried taking down one of the protesters’ signs. The group’s signs are offensive, calling into question the existence of Nazi death camps and gas chambers, Convery said, with messages like “Gas Chambers? REALLY?!”

The sign he is shown trying to take down in the video states “Jews Out of Palestine.”

MLive/The Ann Arbor News filed a Freedom of Information Act request for a copy of the police report. Ann Arbor police denied the request, saying the case was still under investigation, but spokesperson Chris Page confirmed officers responded to a physical altercation involving men along Washtenaw Avenue in front of Beth Israel at about 10:30 a.m. July 4.

There were no injuries and the case was submitted to the Washtenaw County Prosecutor’s Office and was pending review, Page said.

Want more Ann Arbor-area news? Bookmark the local Ann Arbor news page.


Comments: Post a Comment



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?