ANN ARBOR, MI — Ann Arbor’s adoption of a new law to protect places of worship didn’t immediately change much outside the Beth Israel Congregation on Saturday morning, Nov. 7.
While the law isn’t in effect yet, it did inspire one Jewish community member to check out the scene and then confront and shout at synagogue protesters, telling them to leave.
“You guys have been doing this crap for 23 years,” Ann Arbor resident Noah Trobe told protesters along Washtenaw Avenue, suggesting they take their signs down the street.

The new ordinance City Council adopted Thursday, Nov. 5, prohibits conduct within 50 feet of a place of worship that causes anyone seeking to enter or exit to reasonably fear for their safety. It also makes it illegal to obstruct or interfere with an entry or exit.
It will become effective 10 days after its Nov. 12 legal publication, making it the law starting Nov. 22. That means it will be in place for Saturday worship services starting Nov. 28.
Local resident Henry Herskovitz protested Saturday — just as he has since 2003 — as city police and congregants watched.
He was joined by Chris Mark, a former Huron High School teacher, with a bevy of anti-Jewish and anti-Israel signs, including some challenging historically accepted accounts of the Holocaust.

They included messages like “Death Camps? Really?!” and “Gas Chambers? REALLY?!” and “Six Million? REALLY?!”
“Anti-Semitism: Always Earned, Never Given,” read another sign Herskovitz defended.
If antisemitism means standing against Jewish power, then he’s an antisemite, he said.
He maintains he’s exposing “Jewish supremacism,” calling Israel’s attacks against Palestinians in Gaza a genocide. He held a sign in remembrance of Hind Rajab, a Palestinian girl who was killed after Israeli forces fired on her family’s car in Gaza.

Jewish community members and congregants have described the protests outside Beth Israel as hateful and antisemitic, saying they cause fear of violence.
Herskovitz maintains they’re peaceful and not obstructing anyone. He spoke with a city police officer on the scene Saturday, confirming the new ordinance isn’t in effect.
It remains to be seen how police will enforce it, but it indicates officers may establish security perimeters for safety extending beyond 50 feet. City officials said protesters still have the First Amendment right to protest near the synagogue as long as they don’t violate the law, which prohibits threatening, harassing or intimidating behavior.
A violation is a misdemeanor crime punishable by up to 90 days in jail and/or a fine up to $500.

Trobe said he’s 35 and remembers seeing protest signs outside the synagogue when he was a child and asking his mother, former City Council Member Joan Lowenstein, about them.
Everyone has the right to free speech, but the protests are vile, he said, expressing hopes the situation can be resolved.
“If not, then us Jews and Israelis are going to keep fighting the fight,” he said.
Beth Israel congregant Audrey Newell wore a “Judaism is Love” shirt while passing out candy and greeting visitors Saturday. While the protesters throw a dark shroud of hatred over the congregation, she’s trying to spread love and create a more welcoming experience for congregants, she said.
“We’re here to pray. We’re not a polling station for the state of Israel,” she said.

Herskovitz, a self-described former Jew, complains the synagogue has an Israeli flag and prays for Israel.
Newell said they pray for a lot of things, including peace for Israel and the entire world.
“There’s more to Judaism than the state of Israel. Most of us are disgusted by Netanyahu,” she said.
She said she mostly tries to ignore Herskovitz and Mark, who are a two-member protest group these days.
Herskovitz, longtime leader of the Witness for Peace group, said several former members have died and he hasn’t had much luck recruiting new ones. The Anti-Defamation League has labeled him a Holocaust denier and his group antisemitic.
Herskovitz laments stories about the Holocaust create sympathy for Jews, portraying them as victims.

Trobe said the protesters will need to abide by the new 50-foot rule when it takes effect and he hopes he sent the message Saturday.
Herskovitz said his “Jews Out of Palestine” sign promotes the only peaceful solution to the conflict in the Middle East. Israel must recognize the harm it has caused to Palestinian people over the last several decades and “exit Palestine en masse,” then pay reparations for damage, beg forgiveness for lives taken or injured, and prosecute those responsible, he said.

According to the Gaza Ministry of Health, over 74,000 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza since Oct. 7, 2023, when Israel responded with military force to Hamas and other armed Palestinian militant groups attacking Israel, killing about 1,200 Israeli people and taking over 250 hostage
Want more Ann Arbor-area news? Bookmark the local Ann Arbor news page.


